Heat Pump 101: The Differences Between Geothermal and Air Source Heat Pumps
Many Manchester homeowners want to purchase an eco-friendly efficient heating source for their home. However, this can be difficult because both air source and geothermal heat pumps offer unique advantages. Still, there are fundamental differences between the two sustainable home heating options.
The Source of Heat
The biggest difference between air source heat pumps and geothermal heat pumps is their source of heat. Geothermal heat pumps are designed to collect the renewable heat from the earth’s undersurface. Geothermal heat maintains a consistent temperature regardless of season or climate.
Therefore, defrost cycles are not required and thus geothermal heat pump units maintain a reasonably stable output. On the other hand, air source heat pumps collect heat from the outside air. Therefore, this process is very efficient in warmer weather, but less efficient during colder weather. In fact, more coil defrosts are required for operation during the winter.
The Heat Collector System
The heat collector systems are quite different between air source and geothermal heat pumps. For example, geothermal heat pumps circulate an antifreeze solution through pipes that are buried in the ground.
The antifreeze absorbs the grounds’ heat during the cold months and ejects heat from the home during the warmer months. On the other hand, an air source heat pump exclusively draws heat from the outdoor air. Therefore, these units are installed with a fan outside the home that operates as needed throughout the year. The air source pump compressor may be installed outdoors in gentle climates or indoors in harsher conditions.
Additional Differences
Geothermal heat pump systems are considered to be more energy efficient because they can operate at up to 500 percent efficiency during winter. However, air-source heat pumps can only operate at up to 300 percent efficiency during the winter. The upfront costs of purchasing and installing a geothermal system is higher, but their lower energy costs let homeowners gradually recover this money over time.
Conversely, geothermal heat pump systems are installed either indoors or underground, so they are protected from accidental damage or extreme weather. Air source heat pumps are always installed outdoors and need regular cleaning. Consequently, they have higher maintenance costs, yet they only last approximately 15 years while indoor geothermal heat pumps can last up to 25 years.
To summarize, both air source and geothermal heat pumps are efficient sources of alternative energy for your Manchester home. However, air source heat pumps are more inexpensive, but do not last as long. Geothermal heat pump systems are very energy efficient, but will cost more upfront.
Call Skovron Mechanical Services LLC. at (603) 674-9885 today to find out more about geothermal and air source heat pumps for your Manchester, NH home.
CONTACT US TODAY!
Testimonials
"Two thumbs up to Skovron! Great pricing, quality service, and knowledgeable technicians who are willing to answer any questions or concerns you may have. I fully recommend Skovron and will be using them again."
Brad F.
"I have had so much trouble in the past with the quality of work completed by oil boiler maintenance companies. This company is the first that I feel lives up to not only my expectations but also their own values statements on their website. Between the competitive pricing and the expertise of the service technician I will be calling Skovron for all future boiler repairs and maintenance. I would highly recommend them to anyone who is ready for the job to be done correctly the 1st time."
Gina L.
"I'm the manager of the RadioShack in the horn pond plaza on Cambridge Rd and three days ago my building was hit with a massive power surge that ruined the HVAC unit on the roof of my building. It took my company three days to respond to me about my problem, but it took less than an hour for them to fix the problem. I am now very comfortable in a cool store thanks to Matt, the awesome technician. You saved my life, man. I'll be telling any and all customers to see you guys first for HVAC service and repair."
Wolf W.
WE’RE ACCREDITED!
Makes solving your HVAC issue as easy and hassle-free as possible.
Explained before any work begins so you always know what to expect. No surprises!
Who will respect your property and ensure all work is done properly.
Ensures your home or business is as comfortable and efficient as possible.